| #2 | 199.2 pts | The MonStars (Michael, 2012) | Week 3, 2012 |
| #3 | 188.4 pts | Fish Bait (2014) | Week 14, 2014 |
| #4 | 187.0 pts | Kardiac Kids (Adam, 2021) | Week 1, 2021 |
| #5 | 186.1 pts | 2 Yards Under (Paul, 2023) | Week 5, 2023 |
| #2 | 19.0 pts | SMACKDOWN (John, 2007) | Week 5, 2007 |
| #3 | 24.0 pts | ouch (2006) | Week 5, 2006 |
| #4 | 27.0 pts | Terp Cop (2011) | Week 7, 2011 |
| #5 | 28.0 pts | SMACKDOWN (John, 2007) | Week 6, 2007 |
| #2 | 103.2 pt margin | Hands Holzberger (Brian, 2017) | beat SMACKDOWN (John, 2017), 164.5-61.3, Week 14 2017 |
| #3 | 102.7 pt margin | BourbonBandits (Matt P, 2022) | beat American Idol (Van, 2022), 167.6-64.9, Week 11 2022 |
| #4 | 101.8 pt margin | Even Bauce can beat West Virginia Football Club Team (Mark, 2020) | beat SMACKDOWN (John, 2020), 164.2-62.4, Week 14 2020 |
| #5 | 100.4 pt margin | The MonStars (Michael, 2012) | beat Black & Gold (Van, 2012), 199.2-98.8, Week 3 2012 |
| #2 | 0.1 pt margin | JR's Team (JR, 2020) | beat Hands Holzberger (Brian, 2020), 92.9-92.8, Week 8 2020 |
| #3 | 0.1 pt margin | Even Bauce can beat West Virginia (Mark, 2016) | beat Stinky Bastards!!! (Matt O, 2016), 139.1-139.0, Week 12 2016 |
| #4 | 0.2 pt margin | Foosball is the Devil (Devon, 2019) | beat American Idol (Van, 2019), 107.3-107.1, Week 2 2019 |
| #5 | 0.2 pt margin | 2 Yards Under (Paul, 2016) | beat Foosball is the Devil (Devon, 2016), 116.4-116.2, Week 7 2016 |
| #2 | 10 games | Mark | Week 4 2014 – Week 13 2014 |
| #3 | 9 games | Matt P | Week 2 2018 – Week 10 2018 |
| #4 | 9 games | Niels | Week 3 2007 – Week 13 2007 |
| #5 | 9 games | Mike | Week 2 2003 – Week 10 2003 |
| #2 | 14 games | John | Week 4 2017 – Week 3 2018 |
| #3 | 11 games | Tom | Week 4 2014 – Week 14 2014 |
| #4 | 9 games | Matt O | Week 8 2019 – Week 2 2020 |
| #5 | 9 games | Chris | Week 2 2020 – Week 10 2020 |
| #2 | 318.7 combined pts | I am so SMRT, D'oh! (Tom, 2021) vs Hands Holzberger (Brian, 2021) | 167.2-151.5, Week 5 2021 |
| #3 | 316.6 combined pts | BourbonBandits (Matt P, 2022) vs 2 Yards Under (Paul, 2022) | 144.5-172.1, Week 13 2022 |
| #4 | 313.7 combined pts | Stinky Bastards!!! (Matt O, 2021) vs BourbonBandits (Matt P, 2021) | 155.2-158.5, Week 5 2021 |
| #5 | 310.3 combined pts | Stinky Bastards!!! (Matt O, 2013) vs Fish Bait (2013) | 184.8-125.5, Week 8 2013 |
| #2 | 2206.9 pts | I am so SMRT, D'oh! (Tom, 2018) | 2018 |
| #3 | 2117.3 pts | BourbonBandits (Matt P, 2018) | 2018 |
| #4 | 2090.1 pts | Terp Cop (2013) | 2013 |
| #5 | 2089.3 pts | 2 Yards Under (Paul, 2014) | 2014 |
| #2 | 85.7% (12-2) | 2 Yards Under (Paul, 2003) | 2003 |
| #3 | 85.7% (12-2) | American Idol (Van, 2004) | 2004 |
| #4 | 85.7% (12-2) | JR's Team (JR, 2019) | 2019 |
| #5 | 85.7% (12-2) | Hands Holzberger (Brian, 2006) | 2006 |
| #2 | 3 titles | Tom | |
| #3 | 3 titles | Matt O | |
| #4 | 2 titles | Mark | |
| #5 | 2 titles | Chris Key |
